
“And when they saw him they worshiped him, but some doubted.” (Matthew 28:17)
This line describes Jesus disciples as they stood on a mountain in Galilee, looking at the risen Christ. They worship him. And some of them doubt. These two simple descriptors tell us something important: worship and doubt don’t necessarily cancel one another out, but can exist together.
The word Matthew uses for doubt appears only one other time in the New Testament, and it is also in Matthew. When Peter walks on the water and begins to sink, Jesus catches him and asks, “O you of little faith, why did you doubt?” (Matthew 14:31). Peter’s doubt was not hardened skepticism, but wavering trust. He had come to Jesus, he was looking at Jesus, and still something in him hesitated. The disciples on the mountain were in a similar place. They had seen the risen Christ and fallen down before him in worship, yet something in them still pumped the brakes. Whatever that hesitation was, it lived in the same hearts that were worshiping.
This scene helpfully shows us worshipers are not immune from doubt nor are doubters unable to genuinely worship. These are two realities that can be true at once in the same person. The worshiper need not despair at the presence of doubt and the doubter need not avoid worship, thinking it insincere because he doesn’t have every answer to every question.
By doubt I don’t mean unbelief. Unbelief is a settled refusal to trust. Doubt, as I mean it here, is an open question held by someone who still wants the answer. It may be a hesitation, a wall, or a problem not yet solved. Where unbelief closes the door, doubt stands at the doorway.
Worship Produces Doubt
Far from being opposites, genuine worship often produces doubt. Matthew doesn’t tell us where the disciples’ hesitation came from (the whole rising from the dead thing likely took time to settle in), but anyone who has followed Christ for long knows one place it often comes from.
When Christ becomes a man’s delightful focus and study, he pays attention. He seeks knowledge of him. He discusses him with others and listens intently to those who speak of him. In the course of all that seeking, he comes across questions he has never considered, challenges he cannot immediately answer, and concerns he is not quickly able to satisfy.
This shouldn’t surprise us. Our knowledge is limited and the God we are considering is infinite. The gospel is unfathomable. When finite minds give sustained attention to an infinite God, they will often hit walls they can’t get over the moment they meet them.
So treasuring Christ as Lord, seeking him with intentional focus, will often produce moments of doubt. Not because the faith is weak, but because it is real enough to take Jesus seriously and wise enough to know he isn’t merely good, but gloriously true.
Doubt Strengthens Worship
On the other hand, doubt from a humble heart can produce and strengthen worship.
When those questions, challenges, and concerns arise, the humble man understands that the presence of a real question provides a path toward a real answer. He gladly walks that hard path. Often at the end of it he finds the light he previously lacked. With greater light comes greater, more confident worship.
He has enough wisdom to know that lacking an answer is not evidence that no answer exists. So, instead of stopping there, he begins pursuing answers from reason and revelation. He reads knowledgeable men. He talks with those more learned than he is. Since this is a matter of worship and not a trivial thing, he isn’t satisfied with unwarranted answers or hasty guesses. He settles only for what is found by evidence, girded with reason, and coherent with the Word.
Ironically, the path that doubt sends him down ends up strengthening his confidence, his faith, his joy, and his admiration of the God who is Truth. He learns by experience that following Christ is not the end of his reason, but reason’s greatest use and most satisfying object.
Yes, some questions will not be answered this side of glory. “The secret things belong to the LORD our God, but the things that are revealed belong to us” (Deuteronomy 29:29). Humble doubt knows this. It does not demand that every wall come down before it will bow. It is content to say, “I don’t know how this fits, but I know whom I have believed” (2 Timothy 1:12). It won’t tolerate contradiction, but it is OK with mystery That too is worship, perhaps of the deepest kind: trust in a God whose wisdom outruns our questions.
Doubt, in a humble heart, doesn’t damper worship, but fuels it.
Two Counterfeits
There is a kind of worship that avoids doubt like cancer. Though it seems noble and wise, this kind of worship ultimately seeks comfort, not truth. It doesn’t treasure Christ as he is but only as we comfortably know him now. Anything that threatens our safe image of him is condemned to silence and exiled. This is worship malformed: immature, fruitless, and fragile. It is blind faith.
There is also a kind of doubt that avoids worship. Here doubt has begun to harden into unbelief. Sometimes it is a deep cynicism of heart that assumes omniscience is a prerequisite for worship: I must become like God in knowledge before I can worship him in sincerity. Other times it is a heart that worships what it wants and uses skepticism as a shield to protect its true idols. It recruits lazy reason to justify its desires.
The first keeps its comfort by refusing to ask and second keeps its idols by refusing to worship. Both are a kind of hiding.
A Cycle of Increasing Joy
But those who worship and doubt humbly enjoy something better than either. Their worship sends them into questions. Their questions, pursued with humility, send them back to worship with more light than before and that greater worship opens new questions still. It is a cycle of increasing confidence and joy.
So if you find yourself among the “some” who doubted, take heart. They were on the mountain. They were in the presence of the risen Lord. They were worshiping and Jesus didn’t send them away. Just as he reached out his hand to sinking Peter, he came to them and spoke (Matthew 28:18) and he gave his great commission to the whole company, doubters included.


